| Platinum | Kraus' Pizza |
| Gold | Mikes Pizza |
| Silver | Bravo! Italian Kitchen |
| Bronze | Pizza Oven The |
| Top Pick | Angello's 2 Go |
| Top Pick | Antonio's Italian to Go |
| Top Pick | Burrata Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Expresso Pizza |
| Top Pick | Luigi's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Zavarelli Pizza Shop |