| Platinum | A Niche in Time |
| Gold | Hartville Thrift Shoppe |
| Silver | Buckeye Salvage |
| Bronze | Loc Thrift |
| Top Pick | Encore Resale Fashions |
| Top Pick | Habitat For Humanity Restore |
| Top Pick | Harvest Thrift |
| Top Pick | The Eclectic Rose |
| Top Pick | The Thrift Chicks |
| Uptown Cheapskate |