| Platinum | Finders Keepers Country Market of Louisville |
| Gold | Majestic Turnaround |
| Silver | Hartville Flea Market |
| Bronze | Navare Indoor Flea Market |
| Top Pick | Buckeye Salvage |
| Top Pick | Duma's Hartville Market Inc |
| Top Pick | I Q Toys & Games |
| Top Pick | Rags too Rich's Thrift and Antiques |