| Platinum | Gloria Jeans Heartfelt Treasures |
| Gold | A Niche in Time |
| Silver | Angelique's Vintiques |
| Bronze | Buckeye Salvage |
| Top Pick | Avenue Antiques |
| Top Pick | Hartville Mercantile |
| Top Pick | Majestic Turnaround |
| Top Pick | Marshall's Antique Warehouse |
| Top Pick | One Vintage Lane |
| Top Pick | The Station |