| Platinum | Penn Station East Coast Subs |
| Gold | Jimmy John's |
| Silver | Gregory's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pita Pit |
| Top Pick | Camellones Pizza |
| Top Pick | Deli Ohio |
| Top Pick | Dibella's Old Fashioned Subs |
| Top Pick | George's Lounge |
| Top Pick | Roosters |
| Top Pick | The Rustic Rack |