| Platinum | Lucia's Steakhouse |
| Gold | Palombo's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | That Little Italian Kitchen |
| Bronze | Sylvester's North End Grille |
| Top Pick | Angello's 2 Go |
| Top Pick | Bella Serra Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bravo! Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Burratta Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Camellones Pizza |
| Top Pick | Tozzi's On 12th |