| Platinum | Taggarts Ice Cream Parlor |
| Gold | Almost Heaven Homemade Ice Cream |
| Silver | Country Cones |
| Bronze | Ro's Custard Creations |
| Top Pick | Bruster's Real Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Heggy's Nut Shop |
| Top Pick | Malley's Chocolates |
| Top Pick | Pav's Creamery North Canton |
| Top Pick | Tasty Cream Ice Cream |