| Platinum | Ohio Roasting Company |
| Gold | Muggswiggz Coffee & Tea Co |
| Silver | At Your Table Cafe |
| Bronze | Tremont Coffee Company |
| Top Pick | Carpe Diem Coffee Shop |
| Top Pick | First Watch |
| Top Pick | Front Porch Cafe |
| Top Pick | M&H Beans |
| Top Pick | Shale Brewing Company |
| Top Pick | Whole Latte Love Cafe |